Thursday, February 5, 2009


Yesterday a thing called "De-Mail" has hit the general public here in Germany, even the old bull of German news TV picked it up. (German only). For those of you who don't know what De-Mail is (as did I until recently): De-Mail is ought to be a service centrally controlled by the government to offer a legally valid and secure transfer of documents etc. The aim is to allow for official errands to be handled from home. The minimal prerequisite to accomplish that is to register at one of the official partners for an e-mail address.

After I learned about this governmental effort yesterday I read some articles about it and must say that I can't believe it will be a big success (or a success at all). After all you have to register at one of the providers (the usual suspects Deutsche Telekom, T-Systems and Deutsche Post come into play here) and furthermore the fact that the whole project was initially started and is backed by the German government (more precisely by the department of the interior) makes this whole thing not more but less trustworthy. Honestly: Who does actually trust government more than a dedicated company, which in the first instance has no interest in spying out its customers (which the government - proving it again and again - definitely has)?

Moreover: Why are the "thinkers" behind this project reinventing the wheel again as is also done again and again in other governmental projects? There are mail services already and the tools for secure communication also are out there. It would have been much more efficient, cheap and mass compatible if the whole project would have consisted of integrating existing services (everyone already has an e-mail address and many out there already have e.g. a PGP key).

My conclusion: De-Mail is doomed from the beginning.

No comments:

Post a Comment